too much going on for me in what Madonna is wearing.

Over dress much Madonna??? Jennifer looks glam but she's not over doing it which is perfect!

Madonna looks like a vampire, and not in a good way. J-Lo all the way!

JLO looks very hot! Madonna just looks like she stepped out of a Siberian vampire's nest

I agree Madonna has way too much going on in this picture. Remember what Coco said and put the coat back!

Jennifer. Fur never looks good.

Neither. That dress has too much going on.

J Lo... Madonna's look is wayyyyyyy toooooo busy. The fur is scary... and I love Jenny's legs!!!

Much much better on J Lo--the black, the jewelry, the cut and the shoes are fabulous on her. Chic and glamorous and perfectly suited to her style and look.

This outfit makes Madonna look deathly haggard and trying too hard.

Neither.

Jennifer pulls it off better

Jennifer ! she looks sexy in it.

i don't like Jennifer's hair but i like her look in that dress

om going to say jlo

Jennifer looks classy and pretty. Madonna looks like a rich bag lady. Not a good lok.

Vampiress VS ghetto fab.
Neither.

madonna looks like she's still in her costume from dick tracy. it's a bit much with the fur collar and everything.

i heart heart heart layered necklaces on a rather simple silhouette, and jlo's doing it right.

I think Jennifer looks fabulous! She looks so glamorous!

ruff one, i LOVE both,
but Miss Lopez always
looks sexy.

Madge but without that long boots or leggins!!

JLo

The boots are a lil to much.

Ew to both of them.

Neither

I am surprising myself by saying that I gotta give it to JLo.

JLo all the way! My only complaint is the hair.

Jennifer Lopez looks the best here. It looks like Madonna is trying to hard. She looks like a fur covered transformer.

CeCe
http://www.i-style.us

I hate both women, and I think they both look awful, but I actually do like the necklace, and i think Jennifer looks better because of the simplicity and because of those legs!

I hate it on Both.

J e n n i f e r!!!!!

Madonna has total clothes overload. It's.just.too.much.

i knew that everyone was going to say jennifer - since she has the curves that make the jewelry a bit less over powering, yet i don't think that this is a look that either should have on. i don't know - call it personal preference

Lol @ JamieLeah--I think she's right. JLo looks better.

Jennifer definitely looks better. Madonna looks like a crazy lady who put on everything she owns. Oh well if the shoe fits...

jennifer

OF COURSE J-LO!!!!