i only said 'skip it' because - becky is NOT american!?

Skip. I really enjoy the books, but the film looks too shrieky for me. I'm so disappointed.

I'm really mixed. I love these books so much that I don't want them to be ruined by a movie. Mayfairgirl I agree, Becky is not American and neither is Luke but I guess we will just have to deal.

The books don't really interest me, the film looks like it could be fun but I won't be rushing to see it.

!!!Becky Bloomwood is English you cant make her anything else thats just the whole point of the book, the brit sense of humour and the her being in countryside england, london and then newyork... i was excited about this at first because i love those books so much, the only thing they took from the book was that the girl likes fashion and probably falls in love...umm original... i wonder what Sophie kinsella thinks?

Who's the bloke, what's he been in? I like the look of the film - a bit of escapism from recession woe. Weirdly, the voiceover sounds very like Nicole Kidman, maybe that's how Aussies do US.

i really loved the books but i have to admit i'm a bit disappointed in this preview of the film. becky is definitely not american but not only that this seems like some generic romantic comedy. its lost all the personality the books had. i was really hoping this was going to be good because these books deserved a good film attached to it. i was hoping for something funny and original. this is bland.

Here's what Sophie Kinsella thinks hills - http://www.randomhouse.com/bantamdell/kinsella/

And I know what you're all saying — I'm hopeing they've played up the trailer to try and tap into the SATC Movie audience, but it does have lots of tiny clips of comedic scenes that hopefully will bring a little humour of the books to the screen. I might be horribly disappointed, but I'm still holding out for this one...

o, thank you pop!