I hope he didn't.

me too. Sad if he did

Nothing would surprise me in a Hollywood marriage.

And how reliable is Star magazine? I don't believe it one bit.

Wow. I hope he didn't too.

I don't want this to be another case of where the woman's career is doing great and the husband strays because of insecurity or whatever.

I take all this stuff with a grain of salt until there's much more confirmation.

"I don't want this to be another case of where the woman's career is doing great and the husband strays because of insecurity or whatever."

Well put, EnchantedOne!

Maybe he got bored with my little pony. After Jen and Brad, nothing surprises me in Celebrity Land anymore.

umm that is a bit excessive if they have no proof to back it up. Weird... he is a fatty now too. She is hot. Can't see it happening.

Come on Popsugar why put the crap Star magazine here? is it filler news?

I don't believe it a bit! Partly because I don't want it to be true, also because Star mag is prolly mad they haven't gotten any baby picture deals so they had to come up with something really left field- plus any magazine can find an "unnamed source" who can make up any "details"!

Matthew Broderick has had HUGE successes on Broadway.

I don't believe ANYTHING from Star.

aww I hope it isn't true, SJP just seems so happy and together .

Sooo random! But who knows. Could be true I guess.

because Star would be the one to know first?

I reallllly hope it isnt true!!!
and i hate to admit this..but SOMETIMES the tabloids are right on..like with angie and brad..and abbie cornish and ryan..u never know nowadays!

I think it was said best by another blog: "I doubt Matthew and the redhead were doing sexy times. They were playing Matthew's favorite game, "Broadway Divas." Matthew plays Ethel Merman and the redhead plays Gwen Verdon. Matthew is a total theater fag".

LOL!

From what I have heard about his behavior before they were married I think it might be true. So sad....

I don't believe it. And it shouldn't be because of career success because as dancingnancy already pointed out, he's had huge success with Broadway. To be honest, I'm a little surprised that they're not trying to say he cheated on her with another man. People keep trying to pin "gay" on him. I personally do not believe that either.

dont believe it for a second

hello, it's The Star for crying out loud, and anyone can say they are an insider with "intimate" details, lol.

where there's smoke there's usually fire

IDK, I have never really "pictured" them together, and I don't usually put much stock in anything STAR prints, but they have been right before. I hope its not true. I don't wish infidelity on any marriage.

I hope this isn't true.

Don't believe the hype....not yet anyhow!

Bull$hit!!

MARK MY WORDS......Star magazine is about to get sued!!

@citymyway's avi...michael musto did it better than hohan.

I'd be surprised to learn that Matthew had enough get up and go to stray - he's seemed so blobby lately.

No, I don't think its true. If he was cheating, I thought it would've been with a man, based on all of this rumors out there about his sexuality.

Other - I really hope it isn't true but it's not any of my business. I think it's sad when marriages break up so I hope the best for them

Maybe? But if anything it should be other way around ?

hmmm...with a man or woman? I don't believe anything

Hope it's not true. If it's true then he is stupid. I can't even imagine like who wants to cheat on SJP she is soooo awesome.

no way... unless the 25-yr-old redhead is a dude... rumor around the village is that he's gay gay gay.

NOOOOOOO!

well since he is married to the unsexiest woman alive...

Weel, I don't want to believe it. SJP is awesome.

Hmm..interesting...the article linked in Pop's post is broken...and you can't even get to the top-level domain....

Hmm...HMMMMM

the link worked for me

He was cute as Ferris Bueller but he hasn't aged well. She could do better.

A married man cheating (any man) would never surprise me! I hope it's not true for her sake though!

Star magazine is about to get sued.....soooo agree!

um no he didn't cheat...she took his balls when they got married

Is cheating even possible in an [ALLEDGED] open marriage? Sounds like SJP is trying to divert attention from her ruinous Bitten line by eliciting some sympathy, courtesy of the tabloid media.

oops *alleged

Noooo.... I hope not!!!!