ewwwwwwwwww hell no

next

next

Jessica Biel just looks like a man to me.

Scarlett, Jessica, and Eva do not deserve top five status. Marissa is beautiful and I've thought so for years. And, Sarah Michelle, she is gorgeous and unconventionally so. It's about time she got more recognition.

it is good to see Sarah at top 5!

I think that Scarjo is beautiful and I'm thrilled to see Smidge up there! The rest are pretty blah, in my opinion.

Jessica Biel is not pretty!

I've always wondered what the appeal was with Jessica Biel. I always remember her as Mary Camden. I always thought Lucy (Beverly Mitchell) was hotter than her.

Heck no.

Of course nooooooooooooooooooooooo!

Eva & Sarah Michelle in the top 5? Not my first choices!

who's marisa miller? she aiight...

no! and ashley tisdale at no. 10???? are u kidding?! i could name 100 gorgeous woman b4 ashley tisdale

Charlize Theron should be on the list.

I think Scarlett and Marissa deserve to be there and am pleasantly surprised that men voted for Sarah!

My MAIN problem is with Eva Longoria. Seriously?

I agree with all but SMG...she is overrated!

Frankly, a top 5 list without Angie is a crappy list.

Britney at 19? Ha! I love Brit, but come on...

I think that Maxim's list is a sham. It always seems so random and disjointed. I think they must pick whomever is promoting something, not necessarily women who are truly gorgeous. Sarah is best friend/ girl next door cute. Not top 5. Same with Eva.

I think Marissa Miller is hot, and this may just be "her year"/" her time" seeing that she is the most unknown/known Victoria Secret's Models...and I kind of like the nod to Sara Michelle Geller especially because she isn't oversaturated in the media. The rest have been there before, and that's one time too many. I find it kind of sad that there is only one women of color in the top 5 and no Asian, Black, Middle Eastern women represented. Lucy Lu, Halle Berry, Lindsay Price, Kerry Washington, Emanuelle Chiruqi (sp)?

whats soo cute about biel am sorry but the only girl i think its hot up there si sarah m..cause shes not overrated at all..LOL

Did anyone else find this funny:

"One of the Harry Potter stars has appeared nude onstage. Sadly, it wasn’t 18-year-old Emma (though you looked hot, Daniel!)."

All for Daniel Radcliffe say aye!

It's Maxim..

Don't like Eva, she's a stick!

Maybe its just that picture (I know nothing about the VS model girl) but she doesn't seem THAT gorgeous to me. Seems like a carbon copy of what is deemed traditionally attractive (too tan, fake blond, etcetc)

wtf?
but yea its Maxim

Where's Eva Mendes?

I guess my standard of hotness is way different than Maxim's, and that's not really a bad thing.

What a ridiculous list. The Top 5 of any beauty/hot list of women has to include Charlize Theron and Angelina Jolie (yes, I can't stand her but she is beautiful).

WTF!! I never even heard of Marissa Miller (I think I have seen pictures though). Odd list. I agree with Sarah, she is beautiful (and I'm not just saying that cause I like Buffy). Why don't we ever see people like Alyssa Milano on those lists? I think she is worthy of that title. She's hot stuff

Eva Mendes is far more beautiful/hotter than Longwhoria, SMG and Biel. Though her last topless photo shoot was rather tacky IMO.

Scarlet is not that great. But I guess that's good for more normal girls because she's not skinny.

I ONLY agree with SMG. She's gorgeous inside and out. Jessica Biel and Scarlett are wayyy over-rated!

Sarah Michelle Gellar is a resounding NO! Jessica Biel has an androgynous face...so a big NO there! Eva and Scarlett are ok. Scarlett has a nice rack. Marisa has a rockin' body. However, her personality is very flat from what I could glean when she appeared on Ellen.

This list is ridiculous. Marissa Miller is definitely hot, and I love SMG, she deserves to be on the list for sure, but probably not number 5. The other top 3 should be WAYYyyyy near the bottom. I didn't bother checking out the rest of the list.

SMG is so cute... Jessica Biel is WAAAAY overrated... Im sick of hearing about her.

jessica beil is so not pretty... scarlett jo is pretty but not "hottest"

then again, i don't have a penis so maybe my opinion is different because of that fact?

I don't get it. But I don't have the equipment to understand the list.

Jessica biel shouldnt even be in the list up to 100 never mind the top five, she really looks like a man and i've seen prettier men than her!! Eva longoria shouldnt be in the top 5 either

OK so I dont agree with any, really. Yes they are attractive women but top 5? Heeeeeeeeeellllllllllllllll no.
Crazy that Megan Fox didnt get #1. She's the HOTTEST WOMAN EVER

Eva is soooo bloody ugly, not sure why she is there...

What I REALLY don't understand is what everyone has against Jessica Biel. She has one of the healthiest bodies in Hollywood. Do I think she's drop dead gorgeous? No, but I'd take her body over ANYONE elses.

They all are gorgeous women in their own way...but i don't agree with their ranking on this list. I like Scarlett and Jessica (not sure why everyone hates her so much), but for some reason it feels like these 5 don't belong together...it's not cohesive!

um is this healithies bodies or hottest women?

*healthiest

smg? really? well good for her i guess. wouldn't have put her on the list but i like her. she doesn't seem to "court" this kind of image. when i think of the other 5 it doesn't surprise me that their pr people would be lobbying to get them on the list, but i'd have thought smg would decline.