Quantcast
 

Marie Claire vs Ashlee Simpson

Tue, 08/01/2006 - 10:08am by PopSugar
6,331 Views - 56 comments

What do you do if you are the new editor of a b-list women's magazine - you go after the celebrities. To make a statement Marie Claire is not only changing its look from the hideous bright color cover scheme, they are also expanding the letters this month to bash Ashlee Simpson. They have every right to do this since Ashlee was interviewed in last month's issue to talk about loving one's body and then going and getting a nose job. NY Times reports:

Ashlee Simpson appeared on the July cover of Marie Claire magazine extolling the virtues of appreciating one’s body as it is — then she had a nose job.

Marie Claire readers erupted in fury at what they said was Ms. Simpson’s hypocrisy and the magazine’s “cluelessness.” They wrote 1,000 letters in protest to the magazine, according to Joanna Coles, the new editor of the magazine. And she agreed with them.

In the first issue (due Aug. 15) over which she exercises full editorial control, Ms. Coles gives expanded space in the letters column to readers to vent against Ms. Simpson. Ms. Coles adds in a note: “We’re dazed and confused — and disappointed — by her choice, too!”

Sounds like an interesting reason to check out Marie Claire this month besides the fact that Maggie Gyllenhaal is making the cover look much cooler than it has in years.


Related Pop Stories

Related Network Stories

 
 
 

56 Comments Add a Comment

  • sheetal215's picture
    sheetal215
    2

    I like the dark cover, but it reminds me of Bazaar's cover with Brit naked and pregnant!

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • sashak's picture
    sashak
    3

    Maggie is a hundred billion times cooler than Asslee. I have hated Asslee since I first heard she existed. All that fake punk crap made me wanna slit my other wrist (the first wrist was b/c of Avril)

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • KimmiAnn's picture
    KimmiAnn
    4

    Dang..Ashlee should have thought before she spoke.....bigtime.

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • julez's picture
    julez
    5

    I don't think it would have been bad at all if she has just admitted to being insecure, and loving herself the way she is - but at the same time wanting to change something that bugs her. That's much more real than just interviewing-vomiting what her dad told her to so.

    This somehow reminds me of the whole blaming the band for her lip syncing issues - just come clean!

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Critty's picture
    Critty
    6

    Maggie looks beatuiful, it actually works, now I want to buy the magazine. I hear you Sashak about the Ashlee/Avril fake punkness - ugh.

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • caligirl1201's picture
    caligirl1201
    7

    Maggie G has talent and Ashlee is a plastic surgery addict with a crazy father nuff said. Bye Sugars.

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Baby_Lisa's picture
    Baby_Lisa
    8

    While she's at it, she should have her man-chin (which she inherited from her o-so-creepy father, Pimp Daddy Joe) fixed. Good for Marie Claire.

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • julez's picture
    julez
    9

    She's such a freaking moron - seriously - I almost feel bad for her because she is ligitimally stupid. No surgeon can fix that.

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • highmtnc.com's picture
    highmtnc.com
    10

    when is her 15 mintues up????? get a life already, sheeesh. i'm not against having cosmetic surgery, but i am against being a hypocrite. but thats how she got famous, by being fake.

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Fiona's picture
    Fiona
    11

    Sashak I totally agree with you!! She makes me sick! I love Marie Claire, it actually has some intelligent reading in it, whereas most of the other glossy mags are like "100 new sex tips to please your man" or "How you can lose 7 stone in seven days" LOL

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Heatherann's picture
    Heatherann
    12

    Ashlee Simpson is P_A_T_H_E_T_I_C! How anyone can respect someone like her is sad. She has bare minimum talent, and she is a walking talking hypocrisy! At least be honest, don't think were all stupid. Contrary, you are Miss Simpson.

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • keener's picture
    keener
    13

    i haven't bought a chick mag in ages. When i was fourteen or so, the mag to read was Seventeen, then when i was 17 we all read cosmo. Cosmo just tried to make me feel bad about myself so i quit it. Now i'm into my Vanity Fair years, but with all the actresses on the cover i'm confused as to the direction it is going. Thank god for the Anderson Cooper issue.

    My point is, i do remember reading a Marie Claire in an office or airplane. I agree with the above comments that it is a bit meatier than the other rags. I think i'll test drive this new editor. If i find it packed with beauty tips, i may just have to find something else to read when VF goes all flaky. Oh god, not the Economist!

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • atoxicsparkle's picture
    atoxicsparkle
    14

    agree agree agree! nothing wrong with bettering yourself (if only in your eyes) to make you feel good about yourself, but don't preach a different tune than what your singing (or lip-syncing). hypocrites get on my everlasting nerve!

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • tifygodess24's picture
    tifygodess24
    15

    im Glad they called her out! Good for marie claire. Hopefully the Whole Simpson clan will disappear soon...

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Heatherann's picture
    Heatherann
    17

    I hope this beotch gets what is coming to her. a huge reality check. Liars never prosper. Don't make fools of your fans and the public who you want to buy your sheeet.

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • jennifer76's picture
    jennifer76
    19

    I used to love Marie Claire back when they were more about issues and fashion than celebrities. I'm glad to hear this!

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • mirellarenee's picture
    mirellarenee
    20

    Wait a minute! Marie Claire is def not B-list (at least not in m book)! The mag prides itself in showing women's issues from around to the world, from child brothels in India, the missing and murdered women from Juarez, Mexico to sex trafficking going on in our own US soil! Sure I was dissappointed to see that fake dumb a** in it, but their articles are just to awesome and inspiring and in my opinion, do a great service for women all over the world. And yes, I am a faithful suscriber!

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • merryunbirthday's picture
    merryunbirthday
    21

    WOW! The magazine looks so different now.....I wonder what direction the new editor wants to take with it. I already see "Sexy" on the cover.

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • lacoste's picture
    lacoste
    22

    It's stuff like this that makes me wonder why Ashlee Simpson is still famous. SERIOUSLY! First the SNL thing where she was caught lipsynching, and then she was booed at the football game a couple years ago, and now this? Why can't she go away!?

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • abomb88's picture
    abomb88
    23

    Ashlee Simpson sucks, and all the magazines are the same. They all just give the same hair and makeup times over and over again. I don't read them.

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • sashak's picture
    sashak
    24

    Did ya'll know that Avril was supposed to be a country singer, but they enough of those so they re-did her as a punk? Death to corporate music!

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Britgirl85's picture
    Britgirl85
    25

    definately i smart move for marie claire, this neew style looks loads better, although have seen the re design on the inside of the mag which is what should really matter, and a big boo hoo for little simpson she needs to think before she speaks next time.

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Shiloh Jolie Pitt's picture
    Shiloh Jolie Pitt
    28

    maggie looks kinda weird in this pic. but I like her and she's a great actress. Ashlee is just another bubblegum singer.

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • pinkangelmonkey's picture
    pinkangelmonkey
    29

    i love maggie gyllenhaal! she is an extreme force to be reckoned with in acting. she puts many others to shame!

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • pinkparadise42's picture
    pinkparadise42
    30

    I get the biggest kick out of the trouble little miss simpson gets herself into.

    Lipsynching, lol, now this. Always something, I wonder how her pops will work damage control on this one!

    I think it is good for the magazine to air the letters that the readers expressed rather then trying to cover it all up.

    As for their new cover, fine with the colors, but I don't like Maggie.

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • SailorMarie's picture
    SailorMarie
    31

    I agree Marie Claire is a great magazine...the Maggie cover looks kinda scary...but unique...

    The Simpson girls do this crap all the time, say something and do something totally different...they say what they think they should to try and make themselves more popular...and it is lame!!! I think they are both destroying themselves by being so fake!!!

    Both have gone from a certain image that they began their careers with and now morphed into something completely different...

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • juju's picture
    juju
    32

    I have to admit....I wrote in to Marie Claire regarding this! (I don't usually read it, but I was traveling and had to spend 2 full days between airports and planes, and I was desparate for any reading material I could get my hands on).

    Anyway, the thing that made me mad wasn't just that her words said "Love your body" and her actions said "Mutilate it so that you look like everyone else". It's that the whole spread featured her with little girls. They were painting on a wall about how they were supposed to love their bodies as they were, etc. I am afraid that Ashlee's actions will reinforce to those girls that liking yourself the way you are is BS. That would be horrible! She sucks!

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • sasha's picture
    sasha
    33

    I think the magazine is just trying to sell more copies,
    so they decided to start a fued with someone

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • bluediesel's picture
    bluediesel
    36

    Celebrities aren't perfect but if they are going to go on the record and say what they feel about something they should also include, "well in the future I might" so they won't look so dumb when stuff comes back in their face! LOL!

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • ethiopian_princess's picture
    ethiopian_princess
    37

    i'm glad m claire did this. i was so disappointed by that issue and i'm a long time reader. it's a much smarter magazine than cosmo and company.

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • ethiopian_princess's picture
    ethiopian_princess
    39

    bluediesel, in the future like maybe 2+ years, not like weeks later. come on! that was ridiculous. having her on the cover or in the mag was ridiculous as well. my goodness. smart, gorgeous women like salma and ashley judd belong on the cover, not acid-reflux ashlee

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • heavenlydivine21's picture
    heavenlydivine21
    40

    I agree mirella! marie clarie is a great mag I read stories in MC that I would have never ever seen in COSMO GLAMOUR(*though I'm a subscriber to both!) etc! MC responded to my email about Ashley within a day! My fav cover by far is the 05 issue with ANGELINA JOLIE! I would love to see RACHEL MCADAMS NELLY FURTADO on MC

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • 1milehighgirl's picture
    1milehighgirl
    41

    Why the harsh comments about Marie Claire? It's one of the few women's magazines that covers "real" issues. Marie Claire did a story on the Taliban problem in Afghanistan WAY before 9/11 even happened. The magazine has featured celebs doing "charity" work in 3rd world countries--is that only respected if its done by Angelina Jolie?

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • OMalley's picture
    OMalley
    42

    AAAAhhhh, I wrote a skathing letter to them and it's supposedly published in the Sept. issue!!! Look for it...Erin O'Malley (Santa Monica, CA). I'm giddy to see all the other comments!!!!!

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • LShep's picture
    LShep
    43

    theres nothing wrong with loving your body and getting a nose job..however i didnt read the entire article...but i guess it was stupid of her to do that Sad sadddd for my girl !

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • yayita's picture
    yayita
    44

    I rather look at the ashley cover, that Maggie chick is some kind of ugly, i hate her face, she is so hard tolook at

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment
  • JennaV's picture
    JennaV
    45

    Marie Claire....is the anti-Cosmo. I really enjoy reading it....more focus on world issues and concerns and also clothes and makeup. Good for Marie Claire! Please, let this further the Simpson clan downfall.

    2 years 5 weeks ago Report Comment