Quantcast
 

Madonna's 4 Minutes — Love It or Leave It?

Thu, 04/03/2008 - 3:21pm by PopSugar
7,523 Views - 98 comments

We didn't think we'd get to see Madonna's new video until tomorrow but special Thursday treat — we've got the whole thing right here, right now! Even if you were unsure about the teaser, check out the video below and tell us — love it or leave it?

Sorry - video removed. Go buy it on itunes!


on Yahoo!

Related Pop Stories

Related Network Stories


 
 
 

98 Comments Add a Comment

  • kelly's picture
    kelly
    1

    The video is really cool and the song has grown on me.

    13 weeks 19 hours ago Report Comment
  • laura220's picture
    laura220
    2

    I was waiting for something cool to happen...

    I'm still waiting.

    I miss the show Making the Video MTV used to have.

    13 weeks 19 hours ago Report Comment
  • ShootingStar's picture
    ShootingStar
    3

    I don't like the vid. It's looks like a cheap stage, but those special effects are disgusting! ew! I'd like to see more dancing and less children's play on cars.

    13 weeks 19 hours ago Report Comment
  • xlove33's picture
    xlove33
    4

    I expected way more dancing... and good dancing, not Madonna pointing finger-guns at the camera. When they do dance, the cinematography really doesn't do it justice. Also, i was constantly distracted by Madonna's outfit... hate the nude color.

    13 weeks 19 hours ago Report Comment
  • bluegrl727's picture
    bluegrl727
    5

    Love most of the video minus the missing flesh parts. It's kind of creepy. Other than that it was one of better videos, I've seen in a long while.

    13 weeks 19 hours ago Report Comment
  • tamyvinec's picture
    tamyvinec
    6

    I LOVE IT!!! As written, SO MUCH energy!! I think Madonna hasn't look that GOOD in years ! Wow that body! It's really a nice video. Maybe a little more dancing would have been great but it would have killed the dynamic of the video.
    Anyway The song is really really growing on me!
    will buy the album !!

    13 weeks 19 hours ago Report Comment
  • onholiday's picture
    onholiday
    7

    not too bad. i think it will grow on me, plus how can you not love JT?

    13 weeks 19 hours ago Report Comment
  • Rouge14's picture
    Rouge14
    9

    I'm still not a big fan of the song but the video was very well shot, it's got a lot of energy in it and would definately get me to get up and dance to it, as for the song, still not sure, might grow on me after a while, who knows?

    13 weeks 19 hours ago Report Comment
  • fattiecat07's picture
    fattiecat07
    10

    I love the song but the video is just odd. I might say though, Madonna looks hot! hehehe

    13 weeks 19 hours ago Report Comment
  • sisko20's picture
    sisko20
    11

    That's it?! Boring song!Never been a Madonna fan but I was expecting so much more from JT and Timbo. Those to usually do fantastic music.And I guess the video is just ok

    13 weeks 19 hours ago Report Comment
  • cnyc1a's picture
    cnyc1a
    12

    Madonna Looks Hot and JT looks handsome but I don't get it. I mean I do but still it didn't make me say Wow.

    13 weeks 19 hours ago Report Comment
  • CannavaroLover's picture
    CannavaroLover
    13

    the song is ok, but the video is awful. no originality...the conveyer belt part espesh--totally "OK GO" on that. JT looks like Robin Thicke and is moving like Michael Jackson entirely too much. Madge's outfit is horrid, and ummm....where's the dancing? From what I could see the set was all a computer generated set. And to hate on one last point--the people sucking face, whose face you could see a bilateral cross section-of...WTF was that? odd video. Something like Missy Elliott's garbage bag video--i don't get it.

    13 weeks 19 hours ago Report Comment
  • fuzzles's picture
    fuzzles
    16

    I think there is just too much going on with the music. Sounds an awful lot like a few of the newest Duran Duran songs when they colaborated with Justin Timberlake and Timbaland.

    13 weeks 19 hours ago Report Comment
  • Iwillmarryunick's picture
    Iwillmarryunick
    17

    I like the song...but her outfit is very eww.... and distracting. I 'll buy the song as long as I never have to see the video again. Promise?

    13 weeks 19 hours ago Report Comment
  • amnesziac's picture
    amnesziac
    18

    what the hell, madonna.
    i don't even know where to begin.

    first off. i thought this was madonna featuring justin timberlake, not vice versa. this feels like justin and tim's baby; madonna's vocals are diluted in a loop that never progresses.

    second. the song doesn't make any sense. madonna's waxing morals "road to hell is paved with good intentions" and then you have "grab a boy, grab a girl" "four minutes to save the world." from what? from boring top 40 pop? this attempt is far from a rapture.

    third. why is madonna dancing like she's a drunk girl in a gay bar?
    everyone knows she can dance. this is sad. this comes off as though she is trying to stay relevant rather than doing her own thing.

    confessions on a dancefloor was awesome. the look. the sound. the feel. it was original. it was hot. it was madonna. so far, i don't like anything about this new suit madonna's donning except for the album cover.

    13 weeks 18 hours ago Report Comment
  • OChottie's picture
    OChottie
    19

    Wow! Why doesn't he take off more clothes? That was awesome though!

    13 weeks 18 hours ago Report Comment
  • lm5841's picture
    lm5841
    20

    I said "Leave It," but not because I expected more from these "powerhouses;" I had a low expectation from the beginning. Success does not equal talent. I like some of Madonna's music, but I don't think she's ever made a truly good song in her career. And I'm definitely not a fan of Justin's.

    13 weeks 18 hours ago Report Comment
  • californiagirlx7's picture
    californiagirlx7
    22

    It's not horrible, I just expected more to happen. The song is about saving the world but I don't understand how that applies to the video.

    13 weeks 18 hours ago Report Comment
  • Nicola_2108's picture
    Nicola_2108
    23

    PopSugar, you REALLY need to stop putting words into our mouths.
    Did I like it? Sure. Did I think it was OMG AMAZING? No. Did I think it was hot? No.

    13 weeks 18 hours ago Report Comment
  • Nicola_2108's picture
    Nicola_2108
    24

    Oh yeah, and is Justin going to work without anyone else other than Timbaland for a change?

    13 weeks 18 hours ago Report Comment
  • Berlin's picture
    Berlin
    26

    How about ,the song is great energy, the two look amazing BUT i think i expected so much more from the duo.

    13 weeks 18 hours ago Report Comment
  • sailing chick's picture
    sailing chick
    27

    I really like the song and it has the potential to have such energy (especially from these two). I did expect more, but I didn't hate it. Perhaps next time have a yes/no/unsure instead of amazing and hot.

    13 weeks 18 hours ago Report Comment
  • alexlove's picture
    alexlove
    29

    I agree with OChottie about Justin needing to take off more clothes, but I'm not complaining, I loved it.

    13 weeks 18 hours ago Report Comment
  • mirellarenee's picture
    mirellarenee
    30

    Seriously, I think Madonna needs to hang it up. She never had a voice (although I am a big fan of her early work); she can no longer dance so she resorts to passing yoga posses as "dance moves". I don't care how good she looks for her age...it's time to hang up the lycra and live off of the good luck of having made it for so long. As for Justin, dude has gotten so much credit on his solo career and yet all the credit really belongs to the producers (his lyrics are as deep as a bucket). If it wasnt for Pharrel and Timberland, JT would probably have been in Dancing with the Stars by now.

    13 weeks 18 hours ago Report Comment
  • Leilanic1's picture
    Leilanic1
    32

    she is freakin' hot and this video is awesome. at first i didn't know if i liked the song but the more i listen the more it grows on you. i love madonna and think she is an amazing performer. if i looked as awesome as she does and sounds that great i wouldn't 'hang it up' until i was dead. seriously. she's inventive, creative and always knows how to bring the dance music.

    13 weeks 17 hours ago Report Comment
  • Fire_Vixen's picture
    Fire_Vixen
    33

    It's always easy for others to looks for flaws and critisise others than themselves.....gosh...that one never fails...it's amazing people always seem to want to expect something more from others, do they even see in themselves their failures and realize when they don't live up to their own and/or others expectations?!!!'but saying and finding something good is always harder than saying something bad, isn't it.....

    I really like it/love it...when I saw Ellen dancing to it and stuff...it was like whoa somehow, I really like this song more. Laughing out loud Expect?!!...well..I think most or few of us always have things...our own music videos going on in our heads of how its going to be and whatever, but common sense is than in this world...hardly anything actually happens the way we envision it, it's different that's for sure...so what?!! some may think it lame! whatever! I try to never critisise those in better positions than me, can dance better than me, doing something they love and sticking to it for a very long time...more creative than me (yeah but in a different way and still able to get it out)etc. (funny though...for a couple days i've been thinking about that...when she had inside the body and making out..under the skin, the skeleton, skin no matter what color is really indeed beautiful...we are beautiful but yet so gross, it's amazing...i found it rather "interesting"..to put it nicely Eye-wink ) i'm just soooo sick of people taking things sooo literally!!! everything in life is not suppose to be like that, loosen up and have fun if possible, not all of us can be alike...that's for sure, but that doesnt mean to insult or make negative remarks at it and getting so technical! I LOVE timberland!!! and JT, nothing wrong with them making music and stuff together (other people would love for their favorite singer and someone else to make a couple duets together!), why are people so into worrying and bothering themself with these people lives by saying negative/silly/dumb/ignorant things! this place that's suppose to be a "happy community" is getting as sick and evil as on YOUTUBE, everywhere you seem to go online seems to be surrounding with bad things...amazing how people like to live like that..want to live like that. There do what they do and they do it good, celebs are just normal people who have jobs in the "limelight" that are put here to entertain us....differently, each of us, stop acting like they are perfect or suppose to be higher than us morally, physically, mentally and whatever else, they are not! get over yourselves, we all can't do things that appeal to EVERYONE. Gosh I feel much better getting that out...tired of seeing the same old crappy remarks everywhere I turn when it comes to people and music. Give it a break!

    13 weeks 17 hours ago Report Comment
  • mirellarenee's picture
    mirellarenee
    37

    I thought that's what the comment field was for, to leave MY COMMENTS. Someone stated that "celebs are just normal people who have jobs in the "limelight" that are put here to entertain us....differently, each of us, stop acting like they are perfect or suppose to be higher than us morally, physically, mentally and whatever else, they are not!" If that was the case, then why must they act that way themselves?

    13 weeks 17 hours ago Report Comment
  • popsplenda's picture
    popsplenda
    39

    I TOTALLY agree with Nicola_2108!!! So many times I don't even want to answer the polls because of the way they are worded. Just put yes, no and maybe/kind of whatever and let people fill in their own comments to elaborate. Make it work!

    13 weeks 16 hours ago Report Comment
  • misscoopa's picture
    misscoopa
    40

    Nothing special. Whatsoever. And I find the song very annoying.

    13 weeks 16 hours ago Report Comment
  • DarkRayne's picture
    DarkRayne
    42

    What sad choreography for someone who could once dance, it was just as bad Britney's performance at the Music Awards. The song is awful and annoying and I hate hip hop rap or whatever you want to call this crap.

    13 weeks 16 hours ago Report Comment
  • lightheaded's picture
    lightheaded
    43

    The song will grow on me, and I liked the video... its actually something I would expect from JT, however I always expect something new and original from Madonna, and feel like ive seen this before...

    13 weeks 16 hours ago Report Comment
  • desertbanshee's picture
    desertbanshee
    44

    I didn't vote because there was no middle answer. It was alright. Catchy. I guess Madge knows sex sells.

    13 weeks 16 hours ago Report Comment
  • celeb_obsessed25's picture