Ashlee Simpson? No way.

More like an Olsen twin.

she do like ashlee esp in the first pic..but its her.

Yeah, I think she looks like an Olsen here too

No, she looks like Hil to me.

She def looks like Ashlee here but I adore Hilary sooo much more!

I have to say, I think Ashlee stole the look from Hilary. The Duffster has always rocked the same look since she graduated from her disastrous Disney trends. Ashlee has floated around searching for a gimmick. She only settled into the scarves/leggings/hats look when she hooked up with Pete.

Actually, I thought it was one of the Olsens

she looks like one of the olsen twins but hell no not ashlee love hilary though

....OR how about she looks like any wannabe hipster/punk star/grunge girl starlet in Los Angeles?

another carbon copy i say.

She looks cute

i love hilary
no dissing hilary
she looks cute

She look's great go Hilary!

Love her!

She's so cute!

Maybe a mutant mix between A. Simpson and an Olsen?

No, Ashley has a skinnier face

no! she looks like herself here.

she looks so cute! i like her style

that's painful having her compared to ashlee - they are sooo different and their look isn't even the same. i think that her relationship with her hockey player is great and i hope that great things come to them...

I think she looks more like an Olsen twin!

It definitely looks like Hilary Duff to me.

nose makes her look more like an olsen

I'd say she is tons cuter then Ashley. But that's just me!

I could tell it was HilDuff. BTW, she needs to burn those Uggs

she looks like an Olsen

I think Hilary Looks Like Hilary

She looks better than Ashley. Better style.

Yeah, I'd say she looks like a cleaner Olsen.

it's Hilary look at the eyes she's cute...

i love hilary-she's so much cuter than ashlee

SHE GOT STACKS ON DECK (LOL)IT MEANS MONEY FOR THOSE WHO DON'T KNOW

I like her. She looks great.

that's weird. she looks like hilary to me

Duh... that's Hilary. But first, I thought it was M-K Olsen who upgraded her style.

me thinks she's had work done on her lips?

she looks one thousand times cuter than any simpson

she doesn't look at all like Ashlee, hello.

I've got a feeling she's trying LILO's style.

She looks more like an Olsen to me -__-"
Like what most said.

SHE LOOKS GREAT!

That's a no brainer! Hillary is cute. Ashlee is quite homely, and doesn't look like her one bit!

ashlee's nose r so easy to spot from far.. n i think that ashlee kinda stole hil's style a bit.i mean come on! that girl has been changing her image SO many times..n hil looks really cute in those pics!

It looks like Duff

Hilary Duff, but she seriously does look like an olsen twin here. shes doing the lip pout thing. Gah...

Woah... kinda scary!

i was thinking more lindsay.. or like the others said an olsen twin, namely ashley. but you can tell it's her..

They're all just starting to blend in and look alike. No one looks different or unique anymore, just cookie cutter blondes.