for the 1st time, I really don't like how SMG looks!!
Her make up is terrible!

wow, that's too much of a cleavage and looks like SMG's make up was done in the dark.

omg her tits are so saggy. oops!

She needs a little 'assistance' for her 'pair.'
Sarah looks so small with Amanda.

Yeah, SMG is not lookin hot in these pics, but Amanda is! How pretty, she's glowing.

I kind of like the smoky eyes and the hair but the nude lips are WRONG WRONG WRONG. I don't know who was responsible for that but yikes. I would like the dress better if it weren't so low cut but the colour works.

She seems pretty unhappy as well. Meh.

I actually like Sarah's look, especially the smoky eyes but the dress definitely needs to be less low cut/revealing of her breasts and she does look very unhappy in all the photo's, which is very unlike her.

Everyone has off days now and then even Sarah.

Oh and by the way whoever said her "tits are saggy" obviously you have no breasts because all of them over an A cup have a crease/fold where they join the body. It doesnt make them saggy.

gross.. who did her makeup? it's terrible...

SMG looks kinda weird here. She needs to fire her make-up artist, that´s for sure

She's gorgeous but her make up artist hates her, poor child

Ugh, SMG, yuck on the makeup for me too. I could even stand the dress if it wasn't for the makeup. I do LOVE the belt.

SMG I'm a little bummed with this look...

SMG appears to be severely malnourished with the bony body and ashy lips. She should add some healthy fats to her diet, ugggh. And Amanda would look hot if she rocked a side-part; the center-part makes her head appear very large.

omg someone fire her makeup artist and get that girl some lipstick

Love Sarah but don't like the makeup

SMG looks amazing but that eye makeup needs to GO!

wow, i wonder what SMG said to her makeup artist to get her THAT angry...

see i think that SMG looks great there and that amanda still needs some work. i used to adore her but these days she just doesn't look right to me. i don't konw if it's her hair color or what....but oh well.

at least it's for a great cause right?

everything but the eye makeup works. This is just an off day-she is usually so put together.

BAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaad eye makeup!!

in theory smoky eyes, nude lips is hot , but with SMG, i mean SMP, there's just something completely off about the make up - i think they've gone overboard with the foundation and also they've done that heavy white around the eyes that J-lo loves too much.

but her dress is cute though, not on her so much maybe it would have looked better on a taller person.

Before I leave the house when I am all dolled up, I always take several photos with my digital camera to see how I really look. I know that celebrities have cameras, they get them free all the time! Or at least she could have looked in the mirror?!?

I love Buffy, but this isn't her best look. And unless you are an A-cup or smaller, you need boobage support in some shape or form. You just do.

Her boobies are going to fall out!!!

Whoa. Her makeup is terrible. Maybe it looked better with different lighting?

SMG always looks so polished and elegant, but what in the WORLD happened to her makeup? Her smokey eyes look awful.

Smokey eyes are more like racoon eyes. The dress is cute but not on her.

I thought Amanda was beyond tiny... SMG looks nonexistent beside her!

eek! her eye makeup is terrible!

yeh also didn't realise SMP was so small - I mean she kicked a lot of a$$ in her buffy days, guess dynamite comes in small packages lol

Those 2 look weird standing next to each other.

i actually think she is hott

Why is it celebrities don't have the back bone to say, no...this is not flattering on me no matter what their "people" are telling them. how could she have looked in the mirror and said wow I look great...come on.

They're both HOT just too much make-up.

i love her smokey eyes

Sarah's makeup reminds me of when I was a little girl and played with my older sister's makeup....I'd end up looking like that!

weird look for her

she looks 20 years older with that look,though the dress is so classy..yet i couldn't fathom why her stylist chose that make-up for her..looks like she's gotten up from death with those eyes.terrible!and horrible!

Bad eye and lip makeup....poor SMG!

I've never had a bad thing to say about SMG, but WHOA! What the hell happened? Her makeup artist should be shot and fired! In that order. CHRIST!, Warn a girl next time!

Oh my goodness

if only the eye makeup was so trashy i think she would have looked hot